6 Comments
User's avatar
Phil Crivellone's avatar

This was a fun and well-researched read. My son has a tiny projector that was given as a present from his godmother. It came with several classic fables/fairytales that we'll watch in a dark room once in a while in place of traditional storytime. I've become fascinated with the dark and cruel undercurrents these stories have that must have taken generations--if not cenuries--to syncretize. They are always pointing to some basic uncomfortable truth about human nature.

I do ask Elliot what he thinks. He's three. And, sometimes, he can see the signpost.

Expand full comment
Martin Billheimer's avatar

Thanks for the kind words!Appaently, many of them existed without a moral tacked onto the end in their earlier versions. As if the hearer was trusted to come to their own conclusions - or perhaps the idea of 'teaching' some point or other was quite different from what we regard as pedagogy today. The Grimm ones are especially curious, given Jakob Grimm's status as one of the pioneers of linguistics. I would trust Elliot more than a million professors, or myself, when it comes to these great stories. Kids seem to inhabit them in a way we cannot.

Expand full comment
Julia Nelson's avatar

Thanks for this. I understand more now why I keep a very battered old Hans Christian Andersen collection. It is a relic of my childhood imaginings. Just remembered The Little Mermaid having to dance on knives as she impersonated a human...

Expand full comment
Martin Billheimer's avatar

Anderson was genius. Van Gogh deeply admired him and tought him a painter because of the great descriptive quality of his writiing. Look up Anderson's collages and shadow clipping art. Fantastic!

Expand full comment
doug shaeffer's avatar

thanks martin. who in the present time is writing the truest fairy tales?

Expand full comment
Martin Billheimer's avatar

Great question. Maybe ChatGPT?

Expand full comment